Board Thread:The Gatehouse/@comment-70.211.74.139-20140314071937/@comment-24424585-20140314120541

I disagree that you can't have both.

See my comments here: https://github.com/HabitRPG/habitrpg/issues/1753

Now, until we can't have both, I disagree that challenge creators should hold that power. I'm in many challenges where it's incredibly useful to add checklists to dailies to keep track of that challenge. And the way that these checklists would be created are very different for each person participating.

Spend time with your pet-- how much time you should spend with your pet and how often depends on the nature of the animal. If the challenge creator had full authority over the checklist, it would make tracking this more difficult for users.

The "Say Hello!" challenge involves saying hello in your various guilds. If the challenge creator was the only one who could create checklists, I couldn't add my personal guilds, which would make the challenge a lot more difficult.

Having challenge participants adding the checklists does create a barrier to entry and makes things more difficult to organize, but it doesn't make it nearly impossible to do some challenges. Taking away the user's ability to add checklists, on the other hand, makes some challenges impossible to track.