Thread:LadyAlys/@comment-25524262-20141118021621/@comment-24150802-20141123034150

Hi Werdna3232. I've had a look at your application and I think you still need to do some more work before you're ready for a tier. You might like to look at the contributions made by successful Tier 1 recipients to see the amount of work they put in, for example The Keep:Awarded: Han Solo, Tier 1 and The_Keep:Awarded:_Darks_Lanfear,_Tier_1

For this change that you made to the HabitRPG Planner page, I think it would benefit from having the original content put back in as well as having your image there. Images are great if they illustrate how to do something better than words can do, but I think in this particular case, the words are more helpful.

The purpose of that section of the page is to give people some ideas about what sort of tasks they can add, rather than to show them how the tasks will appear. The text description of those tasks really emphasises that you can add a Daily for one purpose, and Habits for others, and so on, and that's immediately obvious as the user is reading the text. However when the user looks at the image, they have to analyse it carefully to work out which task type each item is. It's especially confusing for the Daily and To-Do since they look so similar. The caption helps with that of course, but as a general rule, if you need to provide a detailed caption to explain an image, then it's a sign that the image might not be suitable to stand alone to describe the concept. I think in this case, the image plus the original text would work very well together.