Thread:JiggerD/@comment-24424585-20140116210849/@comment-177-20140116232034

I'm confused as to why someone would think that reversions would work any differently from editing over someone else's work - the badge system is relatively recently created by Wikia and so there would have been no incentive for the editing system (based on Wikipedia's code) to note reversions for badge-gaining.

It's probably just an effect of not understanding the badge system when the original contributing system was set up - as a straight 'X wiki points equals such-and-such a player tier'. If someone wanted to keep using the badge system for player tiers, they'd want to ask Wikia Central how it works or to change how it works.

If the badge system for player tiers isn't working, perhaps other ways need to be discussed - more broadly than between you and Jesper. The trouble with the wiki is that it changes, by its very nature - as a contribution, it can't be 'incorporated and accepted' as easily as other kinds of contributions can be. That may need to be taken into account if there is to be an exchange of player tiers as recognition for work on the wiki.