Board Thread:Contributions/@comment-24397319-20140108150729/@comment-24221602-20140108180727

I want to chime in but I also want to clarify that I don't have a specific preference for how this turns out (so take that is it may). I am a little hesitant about merging pages because I tend to see duplication when it happens.

A good example is that several different pages mentioned Eggs, Pet Food, and Hatching Potions (with near identical content). When I went back and looked at the relevant talk pages, at least one mentioned that the individual pages would just not have enough to say, but the end result appeared to be undesired.

That said, I genuinely believe that there multiple ways of handling issues like this one and creating individual pages for these items may not have been the most favorable solution at all.

What interests me in your example would be the benefits of merging the two pages. In what way do you feel that having a single page is better than having indivdual pages linked to one another?