Board Thread:The Quarters (Q & A)/@comment-76.78.226.61-20140125042322/@comment-24185151-20140215064554

The cotton candy pink potions do indeed drop, but it's all about luck. I haven't received a red potion myself for the past 4 months. :P I'm still waiting to complete my red pet collection, but it's stuck at 2 pets until I find another drop.

Meanwhile, one of my party members can't seem to find a cactus drop (and I've got 2 currently).

Luck sucks sometimes. Furthermore, just because you have multiples of the other potions, doesn't mean you're more likely to get the missing one.

A good example would be coin tossing. If you toss a coin and get 10 heads, it does not mean that on the 11th toss you'll get a tails because of history getting heads. The coin doesn't remember what you've received in the past, and neither does HabitRPG. ;)

Personally, i prefer it that way.